Shellfish Free

  • Smoked Tuna Dip

    Our Tuna has never seen the inside of a can! Served with Corn Tortilla Chips

    $12
  • Chicken Fingers

    Grilled or Blackened. Served with LuLu's Ranch or Honey Mustard

    $10
Quesadilla

Jack-Cheddar Cheese and Sautéed Peppers & Onions. Served with LuLu’s Sassy Salsa and Sour Cream.

  • with Chicken

    $11
  • with BBQ Pulled Pork

    $13
Corn Tortilla Chips

(Chip basket refill $1)

  • with LuLu's Sassy Salsa

    $6
  • White Cheddar Queso

    $7
  • Get 'em both!

    $11
  • Holy Guacamole

    $9
  • Get them all!

    $19
LuLu’s “Holy Guacamole!”

(Chip basket refill $1)

  • served with Tortilla Chips

    $9
Nachos

Corn Tortilla Chips with Tomatoes, Jalapeños, Queso, and melted Cheddar Cheese.

Served with LuLu’s Sassy Salsa and Sour Cream. Your choice of:

  • BBQ Pulled Pork

    $16
  • Seasoned Ground Beef

    $16

All “Homemade” Dressings: LuLu’s Ginger Lime, LuLu’s Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Ceasar, Basalmic, Honey Mustard, Greek and Oil & Vinegar

  • Lucy's Fresh Arcadian Greens

    Grape Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Yellow Bell Peppers, Watermelon Radishes and Roasted Pumpkin Seeds. Served with your choice of Dressing.

    $10
  • LuLu's Classic Caesar*

    $10
  • Greek Salad

    Feta Cheese, Kalamata Olives, Pepperonicinis, Cucumbers, Red Onions, Tomatoes...and a little love. Served with our own Greek Dressing.

    $10
Your choice of Salad above served with: 
  • Chicken

    grilled or blackened

    $15
  • Fish

    grilled or blackened

    $19
  • Fresh Seasonal Snapper

    grilled or blackened

    $29
  • Fresh Caugh Fish of the Day

    grilled or blackened

    $28
  • Classic Southern Wedge

    Served with Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Tomato and Chopped Crisp Bacon.

    $10
Small Salads
  • Lucy's Fresh Arcadian Greens

    $7
  • Caesar Salad*

    $7
  • Greek Salad

    $7
  • House Garden Salad

    $7
Cheeseburgers
Crazy Sista’s Version
  • A juicy, half-pound Burger seasoned with LuLu's Salty Peppa Seasoning Blend

    Served with Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Sweet Pickles, your choice of Cheese and one side

    $12
  • Cheeses

    American, Cheddar, Swiss, Pamenna, Pepper-Jack, Bleu or Queso

    0
  • Additional Toppings:

    Sautéed Onions, Sautéed Mushrooms, or Jalapeños

    $1 each
  • Add Guacamole or Bacon

    $2 each

* Consuming raw or undercooked food products may increase the risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. All grilled and blackened items are cooked on a flattop grill.

All Sandwiches served with Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion and Sweet Pickles.

  • Fresh Seasonal Snapper Sandwich

    Grilled or Blackened

    $26
  • Crazy Sista's Pulled Pork Sandwich

    Slow-Smoked Pork Shoulder tossed in our sweet & spicy LuLu's Lightning BBQ Sauce. Served with Cole Slaw

    $12
  • Fish of the Day Sandwich

    Grilled of Blackened

    Market
  • Fish Sandwich

    Grilled or Blackened

    $17
  • Chicken Tender Sandwich

    Grilled Chicken Tenders topped with melted Swiss Cheese and Bacon. Served with Honey Mustard.

    $14
Tacos

Scrumptious! Three Soft Corn Tortillas with Jack-Cheddar Cheese, Shredded Cabbage, Pickled Red Onions, Island Black Beans, Clinatro Slaw, and Mojo Sauce. Served with LuLu’s Sassy Salsa and Corn Tortilla Chips.

  • Blackened Fish

    $18
  • Grilled Chicken

    $16
  • Slow Smoked Pork

    $16
  • Veggie

    $14
Lucy’s Key West Bowl

Bowl of Cuban Yellow Ricce, Island Black Beans, and “Mama’s Turnip Greens”.

Served with your choice of sauces:

LuLu’s Ginger Lime, Mojo Sauce and LuLu’s Sassy Salsa and topped with your choice of below:

  • Fresh Seasonal Snapper

    grilled or blackened

    $29
  • Chicken Tenders

    grilled or blackened

    $16
  • Fresh Caught Fish of the Day

    grilled or blackened

    $28
  • Fish

    grilled or blackened

    $22
  • Slow Smoked Pork

    $15

All Entrees served Grilled or Blackened with your choice of one side. Add a Small Salad for $5. 

  • Fresh Seasonal Snapper

    Grilled or Blackened

    $29
  • Fish Entree

    $22
  • Fresh Caught Fish of the Day

    $28
  • Chicken Finger Entree

    $16
  • Macaroni & Cheese

    $5
  • Sautéed Seasonal Vegetables

    $5
  • Guacamole

    $6
  • Seasonal Fruit

    $5
  • Cole Slaw

    $2
  • island Black Beans

    $3
  • Green Beans

    $5
  • Gouda Grits

    $4
  • Cuban Yellow Rice

    $4
  • "Mama's Turnip Greens"

    $4
  • White Rice

    $2

All served with your choice of Seasonal Fruit, Green Beans or Potato Chips

Kid’s Cheeseburger

American cheese melted on a juicy, quarter-pound Burger seasoned with LuLu’s Salty Peppa Seasoning Blend

Grilled Cheese | Grilled Chicken Tenders | Kid’s Grilled Fish | Cheese Quesadilla Or Mac & Cheese or Grilled Chicken Quesadilla

Cocktail Sauce

LuLu’s Wow Sauce

LuLu’s Sassy Salsa

Honey Mustard

Honey Buffalo Sauce

LuLu’s Lightning BBQ Sauce

Tartar Sauce

Ketchup

Mustard

Mayo

  • Key Lime Pie

    $8
  • White Chocolate Bread Pudding

    Classic Bread Pudding, served with a hot White Chocolate Sauce

    $8
  • Brownie in Paradise

    Served warm with Vanilla Ice Cream

    $8
  • Vanilla Ice Cream

    $2 per scoop